Carpet mats generally suit urban driving conditions and light duty use. They are the cheapest option but require the most maintenance due to the carpet pile trapping dirt and debris. Carpet mats do however provide the best comfort under your feet.
Rubber mats are a popular choice for 4x4 enthusiasts and tradies because they are more durable and easier to clean. However, rubber mats won't hold much liquid and major spills will overflow.
Bucket Mats are just as durable as rubber but step it up with 3D high walls and wider coverage for the ultimate protection. They stop dirt and spills from spreading which means less mess and less cleaning for you.
Carpet mats remain the most comfortable with a soft carpet pile. For most people, Bucket Mats are an excellent choice for durability, low maintenance and keeping your cabin clean.